Quote:
The controller is a Balboa Lite 240/110 convertible. I believe it is set to 220.
Nope. If you've replaced it, normally everything comes set up for 115 volt pump blower, etc. Follow the white common wire from the pump plug.
My guess is that it's tied to the white neutral coming into the controller.
If so, then it needs to be tied to L2 (usually red) instead in order for the pump to receive the 230 volts it needs to operate. In other words, remove the white pump common from neutral, and connect it to L2.
(Usually, if it's anything more than 1.5 HP, it'll be a 230 volt pump)